Justice Is Mind: Technology and a Troubling Trend

Which is most important: public safety or protection of privacy?

This is one of the most significant and controversial question of our time. In the past decade, incredible advancements in science and technology have revolutionized all aspects of society. This influence can especially be seen in our criminal justice system; new technologies have improved our ability to capture and convict criminals, thereby strengthening our system of justice.

Although these advancements may increase the accuracy and validity of the criminal procedure, they come with a cost: protection of privacy.

In a recent case, the United States Supreme Court determined that criminal suspects could be subject to a police DNA test after arrest – before trial and conviction. This decision has sparked debates about privacy vs. public safety around the country, with the primary concern being a continued trend in compromised rights. Justice Antonin Scalia stated, “the court’s opinion barely mentions the crucial fact about this case: the search here was entirely suspicion less. The police had no reason to believe the suspect’s DNA would link him to any crime”.

This case provided a preview of the controversial debates we can expect to see in our future. The scientific and technological sectors are rapidly evolving, and their advances will have wide-reaching implications for the criminal procedure and suspect rights.

An independent feature film, “Justice is Mind”, provides an interesting preview; currently in post-production and set to release this Fall, the film examines the public policy issues that develop when new technology expands the power of government, at the expense of personal rights. “Justice Is Mind” takes place in 2026, when MRI technology can “read your mind”, giving the government access to your memories, which can then be used against you.

The movie addresses critical ethical questions, and issues of criminal justice, government power, and individual rights. Although 2026 is 13 years away, many of these same principles may be applied to society today. Arnold Peter, a Beverly Hills Entertainment Lawyer and one of the film’s producers, found the recent Supreme Court decision to be significant. “The potential implications of the recent Supreme Court’s decisions are frightening,” says Peter. “It’s not much of a stretch to forcibly tap into a suspect’s mind as part of the police investigative process.”

Writer/director Mark Lund agreed, stating “This decision by the Supreme Court sets the legal foundation to the story in Justice Is Mind. Today, it’s the taking of your DNA, tomorrow it’s your memory. As a filmmaker it’s exciting to be on the cutting edge of this social discussion, but as a citizen the implications are frightening…it begs the question, what constitutes personal privacy?”

Thoughts On Meeting A Bollywood Legend

Last night was a moment of history in the world of cinema. After all, it was a private screening with Vinod Chopra on his very first full length English-language film, Broken Horses. This is the person that has produced epic films such as 3 Idiots, the highest grossing Bollywood film of all time. But besides the high monetary value these films produce, Mr. Chopra’s stories connect with human emotions in a way that enlightens one’s perspective. It is epochal moment to have a Bollywood producer create a film in Hollywood. It is a milestone for the history of international cinema, and it is a metaphor for individuals like myself whose cultures are interwoven from the fabric of Bollywood and Hollywood.

While my roots lie in the Indian subcontinent, I have been fully raised in the west. Gathering around the tv to watch a Bollywood movie with my parents was one of the ways I connected with my eastern culture. It was a bit surreal to meet Vinod Chopra. Here was a humble and jovial person that had a hand in shaping the way I understand my identity. Even though Mr. Chopra has such a large influence over those who watch his films, his friendly disposition makes him completely approachable. I had the chance to ask Mr. Chopra how his interactions in Hollywood have been in comparison to working in Bollywood. One notable aspect about Bollywood is the importance of relations. Bollywood does seem like one giant family. A family the viewer is not necessarily excluded from. When I met Mr. Chopra, it felt as if I was meeting an old friend. His ideas and thoughts have been shared with me on many occasions through his movies played in the comfort of one’s home.

I believe it is this reason why it is have been very exciting to be working at a firm that plays an integral role with Bollywood and Hollywood. Here I am, working in an area of the law that plays a key role in disseminating Indian films to the American public. I feel at ease working with an industry that I have known since a child. This is an industry that has been a medium by which I can express myself. It is humbling to be able to work in a field that has influenced my identity and countless others. Working at Peter Law Group is a historical moment for myself as well.

PLG Clients Christina Charles & Curt Ranta on 'Property Wars'

Landing a spot on reality TV is no easy feat. For those in the business of reality entertainment, the reality is this: success comes to those who are prepared at every opportunity. In this booming segment of the entertainment industry, the opportunities are always there, but the well prepared talent is not.

To become a reality TV star, you need a persona, a filter, and a strategy.  PLG clients, Christina Charles and Curt Ranta, have all three – and we are proud to announce that this power couple has successfully secured their spot on reality TV.

Partners in a real estate business and a couple in real life, Charles and Ranta have landed a role on the Discovery Channel’s “Property Wars”. “Property Wars” brings buyers from around the country to the thriving housing market in Arizona, to compete over the best homes on the market. The episode featuring Charles and Ranta first aired last night, and can be seen online or on the Discovery Channel.

PLG is proud to represent Charles and Ranta, and to provide guidance as they navigate the realm of reality television. This duo has what it takes to make it in reality TV, and we look forward to seeing where they go next. 

Cannes Part II: INDIAN DIASPORA IS PLATFORM FOR INDEPENDENT CINEMA

 Not all of the Indian cinema cross-border activity is focused on Hollywood; with its large Indian population, London is also a center for India themed cinema.  This year, the London Indian Film Festival presented one of its Guru Lounge industry events in Cannes. The event explored the rapid growth within the independent film sector in India, and explored the various opportunities for co-production between India and the UK. 

The London Indian Film Festival is a great platform for Indian cinema, and brings UK audiences a selection of films from some of India’s leading independent filmmakers. This year, the event will run from July 18th – 25^th. Click on the link below to watch video footage from this event:

http://bit.ly/1b1wc8S

Notes from India Part 4: Meeting Gajanan

One of my most memorable experiences in India was my mini getaway to Goa, a small state that lies along the coast of south India. A popular tourist destination known for its gorgeous beaches and unique culture (it was formerly a Portuguese colony), I was expecting a standard tourist experience. Luckily for me, this was not the case. Instead, I was exposed to a deeper layer of Goa:  historical roots, architectural foundations, and the pure, non-tourist based Goan culture. For all of this, I have one man to thank: my cabbie and friend, Gajanan.

I’ll start at the beginning.

When I first arrived, one thing became clear: taxi service providers in Goa are shameless when it comes to foreigners. They would fight among themselves (literally push and shove) because they knew they could rip off the foreigners. Because of this, I didn’t care for the drivers that brought me to my hotel – they were simply the winners in a market brawl. So when I arrived to my hotel in Wasco, I asked the front desk how I should travel to Palolem Beach the next day, which was about 50 km away. I was shocked to hear it would only be a $20 taxi drive – so I asked them to arrange for a driver to get me the next morning.

That driver was Gajanan.

Gajanan was one of the most honest, down to earth, kindest people I’ve ever met. Only 26, he has been a driver for 8 years – and I was the first American he had met.  I told him he was hiring him for the entire day – and since it was 100 degrees outside, I asked him to join me on my beach day, rather than simply waiting in his cab. As we explored Palolem and later ate lunch, we started talking. Gajanan was awesome, because he gave me insight into the true culture of Goa. He pointed out differences in architecture (Portugeuse vs. native Goan), revealed his love for Akon (who would have thought?) , and showed me how to identify tourists by their mannerisms.  For only $20, I gained much more than a driver – I gained insight into little things that a foreigner would never pick up on, and a friend.

Cannes Part I: India Filmmakers Making Their Mark, But Not The Ones You Think

Indian cinema, which was once seen as nothing more than formulaic song and dance films, took center stage at the 66th Cannes Film Festival. In the limelight was Amitabh Bachan, who held a small but prominent role in the Great Gatsby; known in Bollywood as “Big B”, Bachan is the most recognizable Indian actor alive. Actress Vidya Balan also walked the red carpet, as one of nine members of the jury led by U.S. filmmaker Steven Spielberg.  

However, despite India’s prominence at Cannes, it is highly unlikely that the rest of the world will ever see the four Indian films that were screened: two thrillers, Monsoon Shootout and Ugly, a homage to the centenary celebration, Bombay Talkies, and a love story titled Dabba (Lunchbox).  These are independent films appealing mostly to industry insiders and film buffs, but receiving no particular attention outside India or the festival circuit.  In fact, despite it being the 100th anniversary for Indian cinema, none of the Indian films screened were entered in either of the two main competitions at Cannes—a strange but revealing fact.  Indeed, the last Indian film selected to compete for the Palme D'Or prize was in 1994. 

While the independent producers making Indian language films received the awards and critical accolades in Cannes, the real trail blazers exposing Indian film making talents to the general public may be those who did not walk the red carpet, and were not invited to screen any films. 

Indian born film executive Ashok Amritraj of Hyde Park Entertainment has been playing on the world stage for decades with mainline Hollywood films, and Uday Chopra, the younger son of the legendary filmmaker Yash Chopra, co-produced and co-financed Grace of Monaco this year through his emerging Beverly Hills based company, YRF Entertainment.  The film was purchased by the Weinstein Company for a December release and stars Nicole Kidman as Grace Kelly.  It is already generating buzz as a possible Oscar contender for Best Picture, along with a nomination for Kidman as Best Actress. Not attending the Festival was renowned filmmaker Vinod Chopra, the director of “Three Idiots” reputed to be the most successful Indian film in history.  Chopra is in Los Angeles, busy in post-production on his first English language film “Broken Horses”; he is arguably the only Indian director to make this transition from Bollywood to Hollywood.  Both Vinod Chopra and Uday Chopra (no relation) are taking a financial and career risk, but if they succeed their impact will be substantial. 

Beyond Cannes, the real story may not be Bollywood or the independent films that were screened, but the impact Indians themselves are starting to have on mainstream global entertainment. 

Notes from India Part 3: Ficci Frames

Another highlight of my trip to India was my visit to the Ficci Frames Festival, held in Mumbai. As a Beverly Hills based entertainment law attorney, I figured it was only appropriate that I attend Asia’s largest convention on the business of entertainment.  I’m glad I did, for it was a great opportunity to see the Indian entertainment industry from the inside. Ficci Frames is a mix of award shows, creative workshops, networking lunches and dinners, business meetings, and educational forums and panel discussions.

It was clear that the Indian government was very invested in the event, as they provided many resources to ensure its success. I think this is great – however, I also think that the Indian government underestimates the potential for growth in the entertainment sector.

Let me explain.

There is huge room for growth in Indian entertainment, particularly due to the growth we’re seeing in the rest of the sectors of India’s economy. The entertainment sector could grow with foreign direct investment, international trade, and domestic employment. Furthermore, the government could also utilize taxes and subsidies to help foster and promote entertainment industry within country. By decreasing taxes on certain entertainment imports or passing new laws, it would be easier to start projects. In the US, projects may be partially subsidized by state taxes, and this is a major financing vehicle for films. The Indian industry is well aware of the benefits of making movies in America; Indian producers come to Hollywood because films are easier to put together here.

Government investment in the Indian entertainment sector has become more important as of late, as we see a shift from large budget pictures to medium sized independent films – which are just as profitable. However, it appears that India hasn’t caught up with Hollywood trend yet. Bollywood has all the right tools for immense success: the private infrastructure and funding, and a growth in independent film.  It’s time for the government to seize the opportunity, and catch up with this trend. 
-Marcus Lee